What a Washington commercial tenant keeps after paying for the buildout

Published October 12, 2026.

What a tenant keeps turns on the lease and on what the records show it bought and installed. Washington’s landlord lien under RCW 60.72.010 reaches personal property kept on the premises, but excludes third-party property and property held under conditional bills of sale duly filed.

The money goes out in a single quarter and the question about it arrives four years later. By then the general contractor has moved on, the invoices are in a box, the person who negotiated the lease has left, and the only document anyone can find is the lease itself, which says less about the buildout than everyone assumed.

That gap is where the value of a commercial buildout is usually lost in Washington, and it is not lost in a courtroom. It is lost at the point where a tenant cannot show, item by item, what it paid for, what it owns, and what the lease said it could take with it.

At a glance

  • What a tenant keeps runs through the lease first, then through whether an item stayed personal property, became a removable trade fixture, or became part of the realty. In Peyton Building, LLC v. Niko’s Gourmet, Inc., 180 Wn. App. 674 (2014) the same restaurant equipment was argued under all three characterizations, the tenant and its guarantors valued it at $110,235, and the court held a genuine issue of material fact remained.
  • Washington’s landlord lien reaches personal property used or kept on the rented premises by the tenant, but not property of third persons delivered to or left with the tenant for storage, repair, manufacture, or sale, or held under conditional bills of sale duly filed (RCW 60.72.010).
  • To be recorded, a lease and a memorandum of lease must carry both the lessee’s and the lessor’s acknowledged signatures (RCW 64.04.010).
  • Washington’s recording act makes an unrecorded conveyance void as against a subsequent purchaser or mortgagee in good faith and for valuable consideration whose conveyance is first duly recorded (RCW 65.08.070).
  • If a landlord in bankruptcy rejects the lease and the term has commenced, the tenant may retain its rights in or appurtenant to the real property for the balance of the term (11 U.S.C. 365).

What does a commercial tenant actually own after paying for the work?

It depends on the lease first. Beyond the lease, whether an item stayed personal property, became a removable trade fixture, or became part of the realty can be contested, and Washington appellate litigation on retained buildout has turned on that characterization together with the proof behind it.

In Peyton Building, LLC v. Niko’s Gourmet, Inc., 180 Wn. App. 674, 323 P.3d 629 (Div. III, decided April 24, 2014) the parties disputed the same items under three different characterizations: equipment the landlord said it had provided and owned when the lease commenced, items the landlord said had become attached to the realty, and restaurant equipment and trade fixtures the tenant said it owned outright.

The tenant and its guarantors valued the equipment and trade fixtures at $110,235, relying on an appraisal the landlord itself had attached to the replacement lease. The landlord argued it had retained very little that was not already part of the leased premises, and that whatever it kept had little value.

The court held that reasonable people could disagree about what, if anything, the landlord had to credit or pay, so a genuine issue of material fact remained on the presence and value of any surplus.

That case reached the surplus question through a specific route: the tenant had agreed in a stipulated eviction order to surrender inventory, restaurant equipment and trade fixtures and to recognize the landlord’s lien. The court’s statement that the landlord presumably must credit or pay any surplus within a reasonable time, or face conversion exposure, sits in that context rather than standing as a rule for every item left behind.

A bank held a security interest in the tenant’s inventory, chattel paper, accounts, equipment, general intangibles and fixtures, and the IRS held a tax lien on the same property, which it later relinquished. Four parties held or asserted interests in the same equipment, not two.

Exception: Where the lease assigns ownership of alterations expressly, or where the work was built with a landlord allowance to landlord specifications, the contract answers much of this before characterization is reached. Whether a given item is a fixture, a trade fixture, or personal property under Washington law is its own analysis and is not settled by an invoice alone.

According to Peyton Building, LLC v. Niko’s Gourmet, Inc., No. 30840-5-III, Washington Court of Appeals, Division Three, decided April 24, 2014, retrieved September 2026.

As a note, consider keeping the part you control straightforward: a numbered schedule of what you installed, the invoices behind it, and photographs of the space the week you opened. None of that decides whether something is a fixture. All of it decides whether you can say anything useful about the item four years later, which is when someone will ask.

Back to contents

Can the landlord’s lien reach equipment the tenant installed?

Some of it. Washington gives a landlord an automatic lien for rent on personal property used or kept on the rented premises by the tenant, and the same statute carves several categories back out of it.

The item What RCW 60.72.010 does with it
Personal property used or kept on the rented premises by the tenant Reached by the lien, for up to two months’ rent due
Property of third persons delivered to or left with the tenant for storage, repair, manufacture, or sale Excepted from the lien by the statute
Property held under conditional bills of sale duly filed Excepted from the lien by the statute
Property exempt from execution by law Excepted from the lien by the statute
Property removed from the premises and not returned The lien continues on it as a superior lien for ten days from removal, enforceable wherever found
Property of tenants in a dwelling or a place used exclusively as a residence The chapter does not apply and is not enforced against it

Exception: The statute speaks to a lien for rent. Anything a tenant granted the landlord by contract, such as a security interest in equipment written into the lease, is a separate arrangement that these exceptions do not reach.

According to RCW 60.72.010, Washington State Legislature, retrieved September 2026.

I will not generalize about landlords, because the ones we deal with are not trying to take equipment they have no claim to. What they do is act on the statute as they read it. The wording is the part worth slowing down on: the exception is for property held under conditional bills of sale duly filed, which is older terminology than most modern equipment financing uses. A walk-in cooler financed today is more likely to sit behind an Article 9 security interest and a UCC filing, and whether that lands inside the statutory exception is a question to answer at signing rather than at the point where somebody is deciding what stays on the floor.

The same statute read from the landlord’s side, including how the lien is foreclosed under chapter 60.10 RCW, is covered in what a Washington commercial landlord can do with property a tenant leaves behind.

Back to contents

If the landlord sells the building, does the tenant’s deal survive?

A sale does not by itself erase the lease, and the covenants that run with the reversion continue against the buyer. An unrecorded leasehold can still be vulnerable: Washington law makes an unrecorded conveyance void as against a later purchaser or mortgagee who takes in good faith and for valuable consideration and records first.

Washington law makes a conveyance of real property that is not recorded void as against a subsequent purchaser or mortgagee in good faith and for a valuable consideration from the same vendor whose conveyance is first duly recorded, and deems an instrument recorded the minute it is filed (RCW 65.08.070). Good faith and value are conditions of that protection, so recording order is not the only variable.

Washington law provides that leases do not require acknowledgment, witness, or seals, but that to be recorded, a lease and a memorandum of lease must have the lessee’s and the lessor’s signatures acknowledged (RCW 64.04.010).

A buyer who takes the reversion without a contractual assignment may enforce the lease covenants that run with it, and in Peyton the tenant’s promises to pay rent and to occupy and operate the premises were held to run.

A lease signed but never acknowledged by both parties is a document that cannot be recorded at the moment a tenant would most want it on the public record.

Exception: Whether the recording act reaches a particular leasehold, and what effect a tenant’s open possession has on a later buyer’s good faith, are fact-specific and turn on the length of the term, the notice available to the buyer, and the nature of the interest. The definitional section of the recording chapter should be read against the specific lease before relying on this. The practical step, getting both signatures acknowledged at signing, costs nothing either way.

According to RCW 65.08.070, Washington State Legislature, retrieved September 2026.

The acknowledgment is the cheapest line item in this whole article. Two signatures in front of a notary at signing, a one page memorandum on record, and a later buyer has the lease in front of it rather than having to be told about it. That does not end every argument about notice or about what the lease means, and I would not promise you it did. It moves the question from what somebody knew to what the record showed, and that is a much better place to be standing when the building changes hands.

For the buyer’s side of the same transfer, see why a buyer of a Washington commercial building takes a written lease assignment.

Back to contents

What happens to the improvements if the landlord files bankruptcy?

The tenant has an election under 11 U.S.C. 365(h). If the trustee rejects a lease under which the debtor is the lessor and the term has commenced, the tenant may retain its rights under the lease for the balance of the term, or may treat the lease as terminated where the rejection amounts to that kind of breach.

The rights a tenant may retain are those in or appurtenant to the real property, including rights relating to the amount and timing of payment of rent and other amounts payable, and any right of use, possession, quiet enjoyment, subletting, assignment, or hypothecation (11 U.S.C. 365(h)).

Those retained rights run for the balance of the term and for any renewal or extension of them, to the extent the renewal or extension is enforceable under applicable nonbankruptcy law, which for a Washington lease means Washington law.

A tenant that retains its rights may offset against the rent reserved for the balance of the term the value of any damage caused by the landlord’s nonperformance after rejection, but has no other right against the estate or the debtor for damage occurring after that date.

For a lease in a shopping center where the tenant elects to retain, rejection does not affect the enforceability under nonbankruptcy law of lease provisions on radius, location, use, exclusivity, or tenant mix or balance. The statute also defines lessee for this purpose to include any successor, assign, or mortgagee permitted under the lease.

What the subsection preserves are rights under the lease. It does not by itself decide who owns a tenant improvement, and it does not provide for reimbursement of what a tenant spent on the buildout.

Exception: This subsection addresses rejection of an unexpired lease by a landlord in bankruptcy. It does not reach every sale, foreclosure or termination in a landlord’s case, a tenant’s own filing runs on different sections, and a lease already terminated under Washington law before the order for relief is outside the analysis.

According to 11 U.S.C. 365(h), United States Code, 2024 edition, U.S. Government Publishing Office, retrieved September 2026.

This is the subsection most tenants have never heard of, and it changes the posture of the conversation. A landlord bankruptcy is not a magic wand for the landlord either: rejection does not simply clear the building, and a tenant with a commenced term has a choice about whether to stay. What the choice does not do is hand you title to the buildout or a check for what you spent, and I would rather you hear that here than after making the election. If a rejection motion or an order shows up, that is the moment to get bankruptcy counsel reading the docket, not the moment to decide on your own.

Back to contents

What should be in the lease before the money is spent?

The documents that decide these questions are cheap at signing and unavailable later. The list below is leasing practice rather than a statement of Washington statutory requirements.

  • A schedule of the work and the equipment, item by item, stating who owns each item on day one and who owns it at expiration. In Peyton the parties disputed exactly that, among other things, and a schedule would not have resolved every issue in that case, but it would have removed one of them.
  • A removal and restoration clause that says what comes out, by when, who repairs what, and what happens if the tenant leaves an item behind.
  • Paperwork that places financed or third-party equipment squarely inside one of the RCW 60.72.010 exclusions, kept where it can be produced rather than in a lender’s file.
  • A short memorandum of lease, signed and acknowledged by both parties at signing per RCW 64.04.010, and recorded.
  • An allowance and amortization provision stating what happens to unamortized tenant improvement cost if the lease ends early, whoever ends it.

Exception: None of this substitutes for the lease terms themselves. Where an alterations clause already assigns ownership of improvements to the landlord, that clause governs and the schedule only records what falls outside it.

According to RCW 64.04.010, Washington State Legislature, retrieved September 2026.

Any of this may be resisted at signing when it feels like distrust between two parties at the close. But it is not distrust. It is the only version of the conversation where both sides are still motivated to be reasonable. A tenant who would rather spend the money on the space over getting the paperwork right is entitled to that choice of course, and if someone does not see the value in doing it the other way, I would reiterate the risks.

Back to contents

The file that decides this is built during construction

Every question in this article gets harder for a tenant who cannot document what they bought and how any hypothetical equipment was installed. The schedule, the invoices, the photographs, the acknowledged memorandum: all of it is ordinary paperwork that exists during the buildout and evaporates afterward. Assembling it while the contractor is still on site costs a few hours and is close to impossible to reconstruct later.

K&S Canon assists Seattle commercial tenants and business owners with commercial lease negotiation, tenant improvement terms, and disputes over what a tenant may remove at the end of a term. Call 206-507-4009 or reach the firm through the K&S Canon contact page.

About the author

Kim Sandher, JD, is the Managing Attorney of K&S Canon PLLC in Seattle, Washington.

She was admitted to the Washington State Bar Association in 2010, Bar No. 42630, and to the United States District Court for the Western District of Washington in 2011. She holds a JD from Seattle University School of Law and a BA in Economics and Political Science from the University of British Columbia.

Her practice covers commercial real estate, commercial leasing, and business disputes in Washington State. For tenants, that most often means the alterations and surrender terms at signing and the argument about what leaves the building at the end.

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Filing requirements and outcomes depend on the county, the file, and the facts. For legal advice tailored to your situation, please schedule a consultation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *